A decade after the UK stumbled into a rushed referendum that divided the country and unleashed chaos, a warning emerges from across the Irish Sea: it could happen again.
Policymakers and electorate sleepwalked into Brexit and the same may happen with a national vote on a unified Ireland, triggering convulsions for which no one is ready.
That represents the warning from two leading commentators from both sides of the Irish border who have collaborated to analyse the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to form a different country with the Republic of Ireland.
Administrative Structures Not Ready
The author and columnist and Sam McBride, have concluded that the political establishments in Ireland and Britain are gravely unready for a possibly tense and transformative public vote.
"The lesson of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that stuff can arise suddenly and can gain traction very quickly," O’Toole said. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our islands remains very unstable."
Released Volume Aims to Stir Debate
The pair have analysed the governmental, economic and societal reasons for any structural alteration in a book, The Case For and Against Unification, issued by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to encourage dialogue on the issue with a series of lectures that will lead them to Westminster in the coming weeks.
"What concerns all parties, or ought to concern all involved, is the Brexit vote of 2016," stated O’Toole.
"We must avoid a referendum on a yes-no, ambiguous question whose implications have not been clarified because then you end up with an extremely split population where those defeated are not reconciled to losing and the victorious side are uncertain precisely what it is that they have gained."
Constitutional Provision
Under the peace accord, the Northern Ireland official is obliged to schedule a referendum on Irish unification if it is indicated that a majority would approve.
Sinn Féin and other nationalists say this point is approaching, and a group called Ireland’s Future has built momentum, but both governments and pro-UK factions play down the possibility, making it uncertain whether or when there could be a referendum.
Insufficient Informed Dialogue
Partisan language for and against unification has obscured the shortage of informed dialogue, stated McBride.
"Individuals are often supportive or opposed the notion but the detailed consideration which may surpass that to make it possible has largely not occurred. Much has occurred in academia but very few politicians or campaigners are willing to participate with the fundamentals. For instance, what sort of state should be desired? Centralised? Decentralised?"
Book's Approach
In the volume, none of the commentators advocates unity or the status quo. Both composes two essays that strive for impartiality in presenting the argument for a unified Ireland and the rationale opposing it, assembling economic and societal statistics, historical precedents and structural examples.
Arguments cover national emblems, duties, medical care, retirement funds, national debt responsibilities and the risk of loyalist violence. The aim is to educate and encourage discussion.
"There's huge interest in the issue but there is still lacking a debate," commented O’Toole. "Debate implies an acceptance of the idea that there might be good arguments on both sides."
Dual Referendums
A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the Republic of Ireland, where citizens report they support unification but reject increased taxation or implementing a new flag to acknowledge unionists' British identity.
"Policymakers in Ireland must establish what the offer from pro-unification movements is aside from just declaring: 'We desire a unified Ireland and we value you'," said the commentator.
Probability of Referendum
McBride thinks a national vote in his generation is probable and that it might occur abruptly. "There might be just a irresponsible or a bad or a feckless secretary of state who states: 'Let's just do this and resolve it.'"
Both pro-unification advocates and pro-UK supporters have reasonable, justified points, he said. "One side will win on this issue and the other side will ultimately be defeated but each side has has something to gain from the alternative positions."
Appeal for Wider Dialogue
Westminster needed to participate in the discussion, stated the analyst. "This is about your state. It's a British issue equally as it is an Irish issue."